Brought it last night. So far i'm totally and utterly disapointed by it, apart from the fact it looks and feels unfinished with screen tearing and a strange mixture of absolutely stunning graphics followed by PS2 looking stuff, the game feels messy. Oh and lets not forget the load times and the hell that was the installing (make sure you have 10g free!)
The racing isn't much better the AI are still zombies, they maybe are alittle more interesting than before, but nothing that's going to actually make you feel you are in a proper race, or feel they have any awareness of you. Collisions are a boring as ever, just a dull thud and then you stick together for a while - and if there is damage it's not really notisable.
The biggest downer though is online. There is no levelling up, experience to be gained, no tracking of you online history infact no ranking at all. I could live without those but the most insane decision is there is no car/class restrictions or parameters at all to setup - so the online is just all about the fastest 1% of the cars. If you take a Golf, Camper Van or a Mini into a race you'll be up against Zonda's, Ferrari's - it's a truely dumb decision.
Oh and the Top Gear test track is almost a sub game - as far as I can see you can only run 3 cars round it, you can't race on it - or choose anything other than the 3 cars it lets you select from. More options may open up later I suppose.
Got to honest I'm thinking of taking this back over the weekend, huge letdown.