Just had a watch and he seemed to cherry pick bits to slag off mate tbh.
He never mentioned anything much about the story, characters (apart from the NPC's not related to much of anything), humour, voice acting, presentation etc which must be the most important parts of an RPG/adventure.
He has a point to alot of what he said about combat and the freedom of the game but he did pretty much skip over whats good about it as well.